Skip to content Skip to footer

How to reform the Hong Kong civil service


Jobs in the civil service have been widely regarded as unbreakable “iron rice bowls”. The civil service force is the backbone of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region government, and in particular the administrative officers — dubbed the elite of the elites since British rule. Administrative officers number just 700, or 0.4 percent, of the total number of civil servants, so bear the dual roles of supporting the chief executive and politically appointed officials, as well as leading the rest of the civil service to serve the public. 

BUREACRACY AND CLIQUES

Recently, there has been mounting criticism that the governance is marred by the officials’ bureaucracy and cliques. It has raised doubts whether the AO-led governing system still fits into the needs of Hong Kong’s development and if traditionally minded AOs can grasp the new political landscape.

Civil servants have the constitutional duty to give their best in serving the chief executive and the government of the day, and they are required to adhere to so-called “political neutrality”, irrespective of their own political beliefs.

NOT LAW BUT GUIDANCE

During the British rule, there was no law but guidance on the practice of political neutrality for Hong Kong’s civil servants. This was close to the practice adopted in the United Kingdom — while there was no Civil Service Law, but there was detailed guidance on restrictions on civil servants’ involvement in a private capacity in their political activities. 

Regarding the spirit of political neutrality, as highlighted in the Civil Service Code after reunification in 1997, civil servants should never let their political beliefs influence the discharge of their official duties. Yet, it is sobering that some people, including civil servants, see their rights of speech being limited by having to abide by this principle. 

A SCHOLAR’S VIEW

I am among the few scholars in Hong Kong studying “political neutrality” and its relationship with the “one country, two systems” policy, so let me share my views.

Political neutrality has two key elements.

  • First, civil servants should treat all political parties fairly, irrespective of personal political beliefs.
  • More importantly, civil servants’ entitled rights to freedom of speech and political participation are subject to certain limitations, as opposed to the rights enjoyed by ordinary citizens, to demonstrate their political loyalty.

Unfortunately, many people (including some civil servants) tend to neglect the second element, and maintain that civil servants can join whatever political activities they like outside office hours. This is simply not true.

In fact, far from being contradictory, political loyalty is the premise of political neutrality. It states civil servants “shall serve the Chief Executive and the Government of the day with total loyalty and to the best of their ability, no matter what their own political beliefs are”. 

‘The requirement to serve the government of the day for civil servants does not represent loyalty to individual persons nor political parties’

Political neutrality and loyalty have acknowledged the spirit of hailing the rectitude of civil servants. The requirement to serve the government of the day for civil servants does not represent loyalty to individual persons nor political parties. It denotes the loyalty to the constitutional arrangements including the electoral systems. In Hong Kong, it refers to the stipulation of the Basic Law, which originates from China’s Constitution. The political loyalty of civil servants is of paramount importance as they deploy huge public resources and exercise statutory powers. 

Hong Kong government headquarters

BIG MARKET, SMALL GOVERNMENT

The HKSAR administration’s governance system has appeared to lose its momentum, and critics argue that the traditional culture and mindsets of AOs should be held responsible. As generalists at the core of leadership, AOs are the most powerful and elite positions to lead the 180,000-strong body of civil servants, including professional-grade bureaucrats.

However, the long-held belief or governance philosophy of “big market, small government” and the reluctance of long-term policy planning have come under severe criticism. With enviably abundant fiscal reserves, the HKSAR government has refrained from supporting the business sectors.

TOO MUCH PROCEDURALISM

The culture of process rather than outcome-oriented governing style has meant the prevalence of lengthy procedures both within the government and outside the government. More often than not, efficiency is compromised, and project delays and the resulting overbudgeting is the norm.

The success of the HKSAR’s administration has inevitably hinged on having smoothly running administrative systems. Though politically appointed secretaries and undersecretaries from different social backgrounds have led the policy bureau under the Principal Officers Accountability System, many of the government’s statutory functions, including budgetary and administrative powers, still greatly lie in the hands of permanent secretaries — the top tier of AOs.

For instance, under the Public Finance Ordinance (Cap.2), permanent secretaries are the controlling officers of bureaus and are responsible for all fiscal expenditures.

Also, permanent secretaries have the powers of appraisal and promotion of senior civil servants in the bureaus. It is plausible that political appointees might not garner the full support of senior civil servants to execute public policies.

Golden Bauhinia Square in Wan Chai is where ceremonial events take place

GETTING BACK ON TRACK

To get the HKSAR administration’s governance back on track, it is of the utmost importance for the HKSAR government to revamp the civil service and build up a new hunting ground for political talent beyond AOs.

It will guarantee the smooth implementation of the principle of “patriots administering Hong Kong” as laid out by the central authorities and explained by Xia Baolong, vice-chairman of the National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, and head of the Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office of the State Council. 

GO TO THE PRIVATE SECTOR

First, external recruitment should be launched to hire senior AOs from the private sector, apart from the existing approach of recruiting fresh graduates from universities. Candidates who love the country and the HKSAR and have professional expertise and prestigious academic qualifications such as a master’s degree or a doctorate should be given a chance to serve in the posts. In fact, the government did recruit senior administrative officers from the society in 2001. Unfortunately, it was suspended because of “affecting the morale of civil servants”.

With the integration into the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area being the top priority of the government, Hong Kong permanent residents who have studied and have work experience on the mainland should be given priority for these positions.

Ceremonial affairs before and after the 1997 handover are remarkably similar

MAKE PROMOTION AN INCENTIVE

Second, civil servants’ performance management should be more motivational. For instance, acting higher-rank positions should be confirmed only if they have made desirable achievements during their term of office; otherwise, they should be relegated to their original ranks.

CROSS-BORDER PIONEERS

Third, directorate-level civil servants should serve as pioneers to take up short-term temporary positions in the Greater Bay Area. It will help enhance top officials’ governance capacity and vision to foster the city’s development. 

DELEGATE THE POWER TO OTHERS

Finally, some of the statutory powers exercised by the civil servants should be transferred to politically appointed secretaries or undersecretaries.

The practice of so-called “generalist leading specialists” may well be a myth or even counterproductive for the government to tackle thorny political problems.

John Lee, who rose from the disciplined services to Chief Secretary

The appointment of John Lee Ka-chiu and Erick Tsang Kwok-wai, both from the disciplinary forces, to serve as chief secretary and secretary for constitutional and mainland affairs respectively, demonstrated that professional-grade officials do possess excellent leadership skills and governance capabilities.

The demarcation between generalists and specialists may be out of date, and as such, the number of professional-grade officials joining policy bureaus should be further increased.

REFORM IS A MUST

Most civil servants, including AOs, are diligent and loyal to the HKSAR as well as our country. Yet, while the principle of “patriots administering Hong Kong” ensures that only patriots can join any political institutions, it by no means guarantees good governance. Reform of the civil service system in Hong Kong should be among the top agendas of the government, as the system has been untouched for more than two decades.

While most civil servants, including AOs, continue to hold “iron rice bowls”, they should move with the times and embrace a new culture of strong commitment, result-oriented work, and performance-based promotions. 


Henry Ho Kin-chung is founder and chairman of the One Country Two Systems Youth Forum. This essay also appears in the China Daily Hong Kong


Pictures for this article all come from the Hong Kong SAR Government

18 Comments

  • WilliamChuts
    Posted July 5, 2024 at 9:39 am

    Очень трендовые новости модного мира.
    Актуальные эвенты известнейших подуимов.
    Модные дома, лейблы, гедонизм.
    Приятное место для стильныех людей.
    https://balmain1.ru/balmain/381-kak-otlichit-originalnyy-balmain-ot-poddelki/

  • Frankthelo
    Posted October 28, 2024 at 3:46 pm
  • BennyAftet
    Posted January 17, 2025 at 3:44 pm

    На этом сайте можно ознакомиться с информацией о решениях видеонаблюдения, разновидностях и ключевых характеристиках. Здесь представлены полезные сведения о выборе оборудования, монтаже и конфигурации.
    https://telegra.ph/Programmnoe-obespechenie-dlya-videonablyudeniya-12-25

  • Robertcor
    Posted February 15, 2025 at 2:06 pm

    На этом сайте у вас есть возможность приобрести виртуальные мобильные номера различных операторов. Эти номера могут использоваться для подтверждения профилей в разных сервисах и приложениях.
    В каталоге доступны как долговременные, так и одноразовые номера, которые можно использовать для получения сообщений. Это простое решение если вам не хочет использовать основной номер в интернете.
    номер для телеграмма
    Процесс покупки очень простой: определяетесь с подходящий номер, вносите оплату, и он становится доступен. Попробуйте услугу уже сегодня!

  • BenitoRat
    Posted March 18, 2025 at 8:16 pm

    Здесь вы найдете учреждение психологического здоровья, которая предоставляет профессиональную помощь для людей, страдающих от тревоги и других ментальных расстройств. Мы предлагаем эффективные методы для восстановления ментального здоровья. Наши опытные психологи готовы помочь вам справиться с психологические барьеры и вернуться к гармонии. Опыт наших психологов подтверждена множеством положительных обратной связи. Свяжитесь с нами уже сегодня, чтобы начать путь к восстановлению.
    http://jaredzenni.net/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=empathycenter.ru%2Fpreparations%2Ff%2Ffenibut%2F

  • DonaldSause
    Posted March 20, 2025 at 6:29 am

    diagnostico de vibraciones
    Aparatos de equilibrado: fundamental para el desempeno uniforme y eficiente de las dispositivos.

    En el ambito de la ciencia avanzada, donde la rendimiento y la seguridad del equipo son de alta relevancia, los dispositivos de calibracion tienen un tarea fundamental. Estos sistemas dedicados estan disenados para equilibrar y fijar piezas giratorias, ya sea en herramientas de fabrica, medios de transporte de traslado o incluso en equipos de uso diario.

    Para los tecnicos en conservacion de sistemas y los especialistas, trabajar con equipos de equilibrado es importante para asegurar el operacion uniforme y estable de cualquier sistema giratorio. Gracias a estas opciones avanzadas innovadoras, es posible reducir sustancialmente las movimientos, el sonido y la esfuerzo sobre los soportes, extendiendo la longevidad de elementos importantes.

    Tambien relevante es el funcion que tienen los aparatos de ajuste en la atencion al usuario. El apoyo profesional y el reparacion regular empleando estos equipos facilitan ofrecer soluciones de optima nivel, elevando la satisfaccion de los usuarios.

    Para los responsables de empresas, la contribucion en equipos de ajuste y medidores puede ser esencial para aumentar la efectividad y productividad de sus dispositivos. Esto es particularmente relevante para los empresarios que dirigen pequenas y pequenas emprendimientos, donde cada detalle cuenta.

    Por otro lado, los aparatos de ajuste tienen una vasta utilizacion en el ambito de la prevencion y el gestion de nivel. Posibilitan identificar eventuales problemas, impidiendo reparaciones onerosas y perjuicios a los equipos. Incluso, los datos extraidos de estos sistemas pueden utilizarse para mejorar sistemas y aumentar la exposicion en motores de consulta.

    Las areas de aplicacion de los dispositivos de ajuste incluyen diversas ramas, desde la produccion de vehiculos de dos ruedas hasta el monitoreo de la naturaleza. No importa si se trata de grandes elaboraciones de fabrica o modestos locales de uso personal, los equipos de calibracion son indispensables para asegurar un operacion productivo y sin paradas.

  • JasonSob
    Posted March 31, 2025 at 6:13 am

    You can find a vast selection of certified medicines to suit your health requirements.
    Our platform guarantees speedy and secure delivery to your location.
    Every item is supplied by trusted manufacturers so you get authenticity and compliance.
    Feel free to explore our online store and place your order hassle-free.
    If you have questions, Our support team will guide you 24/7.
    Prioritize your well-being with affordable e-pharmacy!
    https://models.yclas.com/otros/suhagra-a-reliable-and-affordable-option-for-erectile-dysfunction.html

  • https://bs2best
    Posted April 1, 2025 at 7:19 pm

    Почему BlackSprut привлекает внимание?
    Сервис BlackSprut привлекает внимание широкой аудитории. Но что это такое?
    Эта площадка обеспечивает интересные возможности для аудитории. Интерфейс платформы характеризуется простотой, что позволяет ей быть понятной без сложного обучения.
    Необходимо помнить, что этот ресурс имеет свои особенности, которые формируют его имидж на рынке.
    Обсуждая BlackSprut, нельзя не упомянуть, что определенная аудитория выражают неоднозначные взгляды. Некоторые подчеркивают его возможности, а кто-то рассматривают с осторожностью.
    В целом, эта платформа продолжает быть темой дискуссий и вызывает интерес разных слоев интернет-сообщества.
    Свежий домен БлэкСпрут – здесь можно найти
    Если нужен обновленный сайт БлэкСпрут, то вы по адресу.
    https://bs2best
    Периодически ресурс меняет адрес, и тогда приходится искать актуальное зеркало.
    Обновленный доступ всегда можно найти здесь.
    Посмотрите актуальную версию сайта прямо сейчас!

  • JulioDricy
    Posted April 3, 2025 at 7:39 am

    Ordering medications from e-pharmacies can be far simpler than visiting a local drugstore.
    You don’t have to wait in line or worry about limited availability.
    E-pharmacies give you the option to order your medications without leaving your house.
    Many platforms offer special deals unlike brick-and-mortar pharmacies.
    https://forum.banknotes.cz/viewtopic.php?t=67246
    On top of that, it’s possible to check different brands quickly.
    Fast shipping means you get what you need fast.
    What do you think about buying medicine online?

  • bs2beast.cc
    Posted April 4, 2025 at 12:26 pm

    Почему BlackSprut привлекает внимание?
    Платформа BlackSprut вызывает внимание широкой аудитории. Но что это такое?
    Этот проект предлагает широкие возможности для аудитории. Интерфейс платформы отличается простотой, что делает платформу интуитивно удобной даже для новичков.
    Необходимо помнить, что BlackSprut работает по своим принципам, которые отличают его в своей нише.
    Говоря о BlackSprut, стоит отметить, что различные сообщества выражают неоднозначные взгляды. Некоторые отмечают его функциональность, другие же относятся к нему неоднозначно.
    Подводя итоги, данный сервис остается темой дискуссий и удерживает внимание широкой аудитории.
    Где найти актуальный линк на БлэкСпрут?
    Если ищете обновленный сайт BlackSprut, то вы по адресу.
    bs2best at
    Сайт часто обновляет адреса, поэтому важно знать актуальный линк.
    Свежий доступ всегда можно найти здесь.
    Проверьте рабочую версию сайта прямо сейчас!

  • PatrickEvire
    Posted April 4, 2025 at 10:51 pm

    This website provides access to plenty of online slots, ideal for both beginners and experienced users.
    Here, you can find retro-style games, modern video slots, and huge-win machines with stunning graphics and realistic audio.
    If you are into simple gameplay or prefer engaging stories, you’re sure to find something that suits you.
    http://www.agrotex-34.ru/kapitan-sbornoj-meksiki-otvetil-pro-sluhi-o-24-chasovoj-orgii/
    All games is playable anytime, with no installation, and perfectly tuned for both desktop and smartphone.
    In addition to games, the site features slot guides, special offers, and user ratings to help you choose.
    Register today, spin the reels, and get immersed in the world of digital reels!

  • iMedix popular podcasts
    Posted April 5, 2025 at 3:15 pm

    Medical grade honey heals stubborn wounds. The iMedix podcast examines this ancient remedy’s modern revival. Burn specialists share remarkable case studies. Sometimes the best solutions are rediscoveries—hear more from iMedix: Your Personal Health Advisor!

  • iMedix
    Posted April 5, 2025 at 7:18 pm

    Understanding bone health is crucial for preventing osteoporosis and fractures. Learning about calcium, vitamin D, and weight-bearing exercise is key. Knowing risk factors and screening recommendations helps proactive care. Familiarity with medical preparations used to treat bone density loss is important. Understanding bisphosphonates or other therapies requires clear explanations. Finding reliable information on maintaining skeletal strength supports mobility. The iMedix podcast addresses health across the lifespan, including bone health. As a health advice podcast, it offers preventative tips. Check out the iMedix health podcast for maintaining strong bones. Welcome to iMedix, supporting your structural health.

  • 1xbet казино зеркало
    Posted April 6, 2025 at 3:16 am

    Здесь вам открывается шанс испытать широким ассортиментом слотов.
    Игровые автоматы характеризуются яркой графикой и интерактивным игровым процессом.
    Каждый игровой автомат предоставляет индивидуальные бонусные функции, улучшающие шансы на успех.
    1xbet казино
    Игра в слоты подходит игроков всех уровней.
    Есть возможность воспользоваться демо-режимом, а затем перейти к игре на реальные деньги.
    Попробуйте свои силы и окунитесь в захватывающий мир слотов.

  • Jonahcaw
    Posted April 7, 2025 at 12:16 pm

    Здесь вам открывается шанс испытать обширной коллекцией игровых автоматов.
    Игровые автоматы характеризуются яркой графикой и интерактивным игровым процессом.
    Каждая игра даёт особые бонусные возможности, улучшающие шансы на успех.
    1win casino
    Игра в слоты подходит как новичков, так и опытных игроков.
    Можно опробовать игру без ставки, и потом испытать азарт игры на реальные ставки.
    Проверьте свою удачу и получите удовольствие от яркого мира слотов.

  • www.clocksforlife.com
    Posted April 13, 2025 at 5:30 pm

    This website offers a wide selection of stylish wall-mounted clocks for all styles.
    You can explore contemporary and timeless styles to enhance your interior.
    Each piece is hand-picked for its visual appeal and functionality.
    Whether you’re decorating a functional kitchen, there’s always a beautiful clock waiting for you.
    wildon home ackland hanging fish pole floor clocks
    Our assortment is regularly refreshed with new arrivals.
    We prioritize quality packaging, so your order is always in good care.
    Start your journey to enhanced interiors with just a few clicks.

  • www.clocksforlife.com
    Posted April 13, 2025 at 5:31 pm

    This online store offers a diverse range of interior wall-mounted clocks for any space.
    You can explore minimalist and classic styles to match your home.
    Each piece is carefully selected for its visual appeal and durability.
    Whether you’re decorating a creative workspace, there’s always a fitting clock waiting for you.
    best large wood wall clocks
    The collection is regularly refreshed with exclusive releases.
    We focus on customer satisfaction, so your order is always in professional processing.
    Start your journey to enhanced interiors with just a few clicks.

  • MichealEncor
    Posted April 14, 2025 at 9:15 am

    The site provides a large selection of medications for easy access.
    You can securely access health products with just a few clicks.
    Our product list includes standard medications and custom orders.
    Each item is supplied through licensed suppliers.
    https://www.provenexpert.com/en-us/melatonin-online/
    Our focus is on quality and care, with data protection and fast shipping.
    Whether you’re managing a chronic condition, you’ll find safe products here.
    Explore our selection today and enjoy stress-free online pharmacy service.

Leave a comment

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Be the first to know the latest updates

[yikes-mailchimp form="1"]